I think what this conversation is dancing around is that we have a colloquial definition of “Artificial Intelligence”, inherited from science fiction and broadly (albeit with much specific variation) understood as “conscious machine”…
…and then we have a set of computer programs that are - fundamentally - no different from any other program (one Turing machine can, in principle, run all the same algorithms as any other Turing machine). Yes, we can technically describe these programs with the words “artificial” and “intelligent”, but doing so is kind of disingenuous, given the cultural association that predates any use of the term in comp sci fields.
totally different conversation, but its also a fun one:
Even if we were delusional enough to think life came from non-life and developed intelligence by random chance and natural selection
yeah I won’t discount the possibility that life has other origins. At the same time, you gotta deal with Occam’s Razor: working with what we currently know about the history of the planet, life emerging from non-life requires fewer assumptions. It also cannot be discounted as a possibility.
I think what this conversation is dancing around is that we have a colloquial definition of “Artificial Intelligence”, inherited from science fiction and broadly (albeit with much specific variation) understood as “conscious machine”…
…and then we have a set of computer programs that are - fundamentally - no different from any other program (one Turing machine can, in principle, run all the same algorithms as any other Turing machine). Yes, we can technically describe these programs with the words “artificial” and “intelligent”, but doing so is kind of disingenuous, given the cultural association that predates any use of the term in comp sci fields.
totally different conversation, but its also a fun one:
yeah I won’t discount the possibility that life has other origins. At the same time, you gotta deal with Occam’s Razor: working with what we currently know about the history of the planet, life emerging from non-life requires fewer assumptions. It also cannot be discounted as a possibility.